4lb - Chuck Roast
2 - Big Bell Peppers sliced
1 - Big Red Onion sliced
3 - Big Jalapenos Sliced seed and all
6 - Garlic Cloves mince
1/4 - cup Worcestershire Sauce
1 - 12oz Bottle Guinness Extra Stout
Kosher Salt and Black Pepper

Heavily season Chuck roast with salt and pepper and cook on a grill or smoker indirect in the 245º-260º range. You can add smoke wood if you prefer, I did not. Cook until the internal temperature reaches 165º.

While the roast is cooking, add the remaining ingredients in 13 x 9 or similar aluminum pan or oven safe pan.

Once the roast hits 165º, place into pan directly on top of vegetable mixture and cover tightly with foil. Cook roast in smoker or oven at 350º for 2.5-3hrs or until roast is fork tender. Once meat is tender, shred all of the meat in the liquid and mix thoroughly and continue to cook until the liquid reduces by half.

Serve meat on hard rolls with your choice of cheese. We used pepper jack on some and gorgonzola on some and liked both, but provolone, swiss, etc., would work perfectly fine. Horseradish would be another good condiment.

Larry, this looks SPECTACULAR! Wife wants me to do this recipe NOW
I'm not sure I can get the WSM up to 350' for 2 to 3 hours, but the oven is a good idea to close the deal.
Larry, your grate, on the grill? Can I ask where you got them? I've been looking high and low for cast grates for my 22.5 Weber OTG and I can not find them anywhere.
Thankyou.

quote:

Originally posted by Jim Lampe:
Larry, this looks SPECTACULAR! Wife wants me to do this recipe NOW
I'm not sure I can get the WSM up to 350' for 2 to 3 hours, but the oven is a good idea to close the deal.
Larry, your grate, on the grill? Can I ask where you got them? I've been looking high and low for cast grates for my 22.5 Weber OTG and I can not find them anywhere.
Thankyou.

Hmmmm .. I seem to remember that same question coming up yesterday...And I answered it. Oh, I get it...

Bill

Hey Thanks Bill! I left the forum Sunday morning for groceries after posting and I could not remember where I posted when I returned.
Thanks again!!

quote:

Originally posted by Jim Lampe:
Larry, this looks SPECTACULAR! Wife wants me to do this recipe NOW
I'm not sure I can get the WSM up to 350' for 2 to 3 hours, but the oven is a good idea to close the deal.
Larry, your grate, on the grill? Can I ask where you got them? I've been looking high and low for cast grates for my 22.5 Weber OTG and I can not find them anywhere.
Thankyou.

Jim, the oven is perfectly fine for the second half of the cook, cooking on the WSM or grill would provide no benefit since the dish is foiled. Matter of fact, I took this off the grill to make room for the chicken wings.

Larry,

As I said in the grilling forum, this sounds so good! I'm going to do this very soon and want to work out the timing. About how long did it take for the 4# chuck roast to get to 165º at the 245º-260º range? I know every piece of meat is different, just looking for approximates.

Thanks in advance!
DC

quote:

Originally posted by Don Cash:
Larry,

As I said in the grilling forum, this sounds so good! I'm going to do this very soon and want to work out the timing. About how long did it take for the 4# chuck roast to get to 165º at the 245º-260º range? I know every piece of meat is different, just looking for approximates.

Thanks in advance!
DC

Don, if I recall correctly about 2.5 hours. You could certainly go with a higher heat to speed up the process, especially since it's braising in liquide for the remainder of the cook, unlike typical shredded beef.

quote:

Originally posted by Larry Wolfe:
Don, if I recall correctly about 2.5 hours. You could certainly go with a higher heat to speed up the process

The way that looks, no way I'm altering your recipe! I'll plan on 6 hours.

Thanks!!

Larry, a spectacular recipe!! My wife had "seconds" and I have never seen that before with any food. Could not find a hard roll (unreal), so we used a french Batard loaf - sliced off 4" and we were off and running. Thanks for the pleasurable experience!

quote:

Originally posted by Cliff Parham:
Larry, a spectacular recipe!! My wife had "seconds" and I have never seen that before with any food. Could not find a hard roll (unreal), so we used a french Batard loaf - sliced off 4" and we were off and running. Thanks for the pleasurable experience!

Glad you and your wife enjoyed it!!

Larry,

I'm doing this recipe right now and am currently in the finishing in the oven stage. I had the thermometer in the meat and noticed that it hit 200 degrees fairly quickly (in about an hour). I thought 200 was when beef needed to be pulled but it's still a little tough. It's been about 2.5 hours since I put it in the oven and am wondering how much longer I should go. I just checked and the middle of the roast is not "pull worthy". The outer edges were ready to be pulled but the middle just wasn't there yet. I am assuming I'll just need to let it go for another 45mins or so..

Any tips are appreciated! It smells incredible in here!

Thanks,
Pat

quote:

Originally posted by P.Schaff:
Larry,

I'm doing this recipe right now and am currently in the finishing in the oven stage. I had the thermometer in the meat and noticed that it hit 200 degrees fairly quickly (in about an hour). I thought 200 was when beef needed to be pulled but it's still a little tough. It's been about 2.5 hours since I put it in the oven and am wondering how much longer I should go. I just checked and the middle of the roast is not "pull worthy". The outer edges were ready to be pulled but the middle just wasn't there yet. I am assuming I'll just need to let it go for another 45mins or so..

Any tips are appreciated! It smells incredible in here!

Thanks,
Pat

Pat, sorry I didn't see this until today, so obviously I'm too late. But with chucks, you really need to just cook until you can insert a fork and twist them like spaghetti. Generally you can start checking around 195º-200º but they're not done until they're tender and they can be stubborn!!

How did it turn out?

Larry it turned out GREAT! I gave it another hour or so and then the meat pulled beautifully. You're right, some pieces of meat are just more stubborn than others and I think I had a particularly fiesty one this time around.

Sorry no pictures this time, camera battery was drained. I particularly enjoyed the spice level, as I like things to have a good kick. For those that don't enjoy heavy heat they might think about removing the seeds from the jalapenos, but that's the only comment I have on this wonderful dish.